Transparency Disclosure – We may receive a referral fee (at no additional cost to the buyer) for products purchased through the links on our site or other applicable pages. To learn more, please read our full disclosure page here. We also encourage you to read about how we may research and/or test Products here.
Had enough of your old and saggy bed? Or maybe you still love it but want to spring new life into it and make it more comfortable.
You will benefit from a mattress topper or even cheaper pads. Yes, it’s very similar but not the same.
More about this later in this article…
Sizes, materials, and quality can vary a LOT, so more expensive doesn’t always mean better and cheap (crappy) ones can even worsen your sleeping experience. We definitely don’t want that.
After testing more than 30 products, we have decided to make a list of five best mattress toppers you can buy in 2018 and five of our favorite pads (just to divide these two categories). Our aim here is to make your life easier and to save you a lot of time.
Our Top Rated Mattress Toppers Comparisons and Ratings
And 5 Best Rated Mattress Pads Compared
Benefits of Using a Bed Topper
A simple and affordable yet appropriate and carefully hand-picked mattress topper could easily provide a range of benefits and spare you a serious amount of cash. Here are some of the benefits associated with a great bed pad, as they are also called.
- It’s a Cost-Efficient Alternative
As you may be aware of, a brand new and great mattress could easily cost you a small fortune. And, as you already know, failing to pick one which is capable of bringing the necessary support and comfort could result in unpleasant aching throughout your entire body. A bed pad, on the other hand, is cheap and it’s going to provide you with everything you may need.
- Extends the life of your mattress
The topper is definitely going to extend the life of your mattress (find out how long they typically last). So even if it’s brand new, you might want to consider supplementing it with a comprehensive topper. This is due to the fact that it would add more height to it and you wouldn’t be sleeping on the mattress so much as on the topper. This would reduce the wear and tear of the former.
- It’s comfortable
Not only is a topper comfortable, but it’s also customizable. You can pick the mattress pad you need based on the specifications of your current bed. For example, if you have a firmer mattress, you might want to adjust that by adding a softer topper to increase the comfort and vice versa.
- It sleeps cool
The majority of the mattress toppers, such as the ones we’ll be reviewing down below, are perfectly well ventilated. This is going to ensure that the airflow is consistent and that the sleeping temperature is kept fairly regular throughout the entire night.
- It’s eco-friendly
There are quite a lot of different materials that you can pick for but the truth is that most of them are eco-friendly. Examples include bamboo toppers as well as natural latex ones which are free of any toxic chemicals.
Fibromyalgia is a disorder that can cause fatigue, muscle pain, and a lot of tender points on the body. The New Life Outlook recommends a mattress topper for anyone that suffers from fibromyalgia (memory foam is preferred).
In addition to fibromyalgia, a bed pad is a great choice for anyone that suffers from chronic back pain or hip pain (see our hip pain relief mattress pads).
As you can see, there are quite a lot of different perks of using a topper and this is undoubtedly something that you might want to take into proper consideration.
Mattress Toppers Reviews
Sleep on Latex Pure Green Topper (Best Overall)
- Three Firmness Levels
- Optional Organic Cotton Cover
- Fantastic cooling and breathability
- 100% Natural Materials
OVERALL RATING: 9.7 out of 10
Pure Green topper from Sleep on Latex comes in three firmness levels (Soft, medium, and firm). The soft model is the most popular. This is good news because depending on your mattress you can decrease firmness by as much as 30%. Constructed from 100% natural Dunlop latex, it ensures maximum breathability and cooling without any flame retardants or chemicals. It is supportive and bouncy and can create a completely different feel when you sleep on it. You should never experience loss of support, just an overall softer feel.
It’s worth mentioning that you can opt for an organic cotton cover that will provide a bit more protection. It comes with 30 days trial period and 5-year warranty.
Overall, considering the price range and overall quality, Sleep on Latex gets our top rated mattress topper award. It will bring a new life to your bed and serve you for years to come.
Lucid 3-Inch Gel Foam Topper
- Memory Foam for comfort
- Excellent breathability and cooling
- Special formulation to improve ventilation
OVERALL RATING: 9.4 out of 10
The Lucid 3-Inch Gel Foam Topper from Lucid offers 3 inches of comfortable support at an affordable price. The memory foam structure includes many air pockets to ensure that air is able to move inside it.
The foam is formulated to ensure optimal ventilation and then infused with gel to further help regulate sleeping temperature. This keeps you cool and comfortable all-night long.
The memory foam provides excellent pressure relief and molds to the shape of your body bouncing back into shape when you get up in the morning.
The size is good – for example, the queen size mattress topper measures 60” x 80”.
This is a soft mattress topper that will keep its shape and give you a comfortable night’s sleep. The reason that it doesn’t take the top position is that it does not come with a cover. It would have been nice if it did, but it is not essential.
Sleep Innovations 4-Inch Dual Layer Mattress Topper
- Excellent breathability and comfort
- “Like sleeping on a ”
- Comes with an easily cleanable cover
- Quilted top with fiber fill for additional softness
OVERALL RATING: 9.3 out of 10
The design of the Sleep Innovations Dual Layer Mattress Topper from Sleep Innovations makes it clear that the manufacturers take your comfort seriously. Constructed of two different layers, this topper combines the pressure support of memory foam and the softness of fiber fill.
The base of this product is made of 2-inch memory foam, infused with cooling gel, to ensure that you get the support you need to relieve painful pressure spots in your body.
The top layer is fiber-filled and quilted to ensure softness. Sink into the top layer and have a great night’s sleep. The two layers together can transform even the firmest bed into a soft, comfortable space.
For convenience, a removable cover is included. It can be washed and dried as normal, making cleanup a breeze.
Ultimate Dreams Queen 3″ Talalay Latex Soft Mattress
- Three firmness levels
- Natural bamboo fabric cover
- Made of Talalay latex
- Great support and comfort
OVERALL RATING: 9.2 out of 10
The Ultimate Dreams Talalay Latex Soft Mattress from Dreamfoam Bedding combines the very best in comfort and support. Choose the level of firmness that suits you.
The soft option adds extra softness to a firm bed. The medium layer helps with pressure relief and adds some softness as well. It is ideal to use for a sofa bed. If you are happy with how firm your bed is but want pressure relief, the firm option will provide the extra support without added softness.
The Talalaly latex is four times more breathable than the normal foam or memory foam and offers about 33% more pressure relief. The latex gives a nice bounce to your bed and is extremely comfortable to sleep on.
The cover is a light cream color and has a soft feel to it. It is removable and washable.
Zinus 4 Inch Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper
- Top notch breathability
- Extremely comfortable
- Supportive underlayer
- Biofoam improves freshness
OVERALL RATING: 8.9 out of 10
The Zinus 4 Inch Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper from Zinus is constructed from two different types of foam. The top layer of gel-infused memory biofoam is two-inches thick and provides excellent pressure relief. It is very breathable and will keep you cooler at night.
The two-inch layer of support foam underneath provides excellent support.
Biofoam is used instead of petroleum products when the memory foam is made and includes green tea extracts and activated charcoal to help neutralize odors.
If your mattress is no longer offering sufficient support, or if it is a new one and offering too much support, this topper is an excellent way to make your bed the comfortable sanctuary it is meant to be again.
Mattress Pad Reviews
Slumber Cloud – Nacreous Pad (Exceptional Cooling)
- Outlast Phase Change Material
- Cooling or Heating Properties
- No off-gassing
- Machine Washable
OVERALL RATING: 9.7 out of 10
Cloud Slumber nacreous is made from Outlast viscose fabric that has fantastic temperature regulation properties due to Phase Change technology. Specifically, this material cools you down when you sleep hot and heats you up as your body temperature drops.
Most of us looking to buy a quality mattress pad usually want to make our sleeping surface softer and more comfortable. Nacreous does a good job at adding more padding and cushion on top of your mattress, and it provides slightly more pressure relief. Although, it’s not going to be a major change in the overall feel. For a complete overhaul, you can buy one of the toppers with this pad, and it will create a far better surface than any cheaper bed.
What you will instantly notice is a fantastic and cool feel when you get in bed. After only a few minutes the material will adapt to your body and provide the optimal temperature. You can even use it without sheets, it’s also hypoallergenic, and it doesn’t have any off-gassing.
If you tend to sleep “hot” and you are looking for a bit more padding, Nacreous will be ideal for you. If I had to choose between this and a thicker topper, I’d choose this any day of the week. Slumber Cloud is also our #1 pick overall and a winner for cooling mattress pad category.
eLuxury Supply Extra plush bamboo Pillow Top Mattress Pad
- No flame retardant chemicals used
- Good breathability
- Bamboo-blend cover
- Has a skirt
OVERALL RATING: 9.5 out of 10
The Bamboo Mattress Pad from Exceptional Sheets acts like a cooling mattress cover. It is well-constructed with strong stitching and Revoloft Cluster Fiber. This cooling mattress pad is ideal for hot sleepers and for those who want a more luxurious sleeping experience.
The quilted top keeps the fibers evenly distributed. The high-quality fiber fill will not clump and is very durable. It feels similar to a down cover but is hypoallergenic and not at all prickly.
The bamboo-blend cover feels soft and silky to the touch and helps to keep you cool. The skirt attached to the pad keeps it securely in place, for even the most active sleeper.
This is as comfortable as your favorite fluffy topper. It can be used on its own to lend a soft, comfortable feel to a firm bed. It can be paired with a memory foam topper to improve breathability and add extra comfort.
The Quilted Fitted Mattress Pad (Best Budget Option)
- Best Budget Option
- Includes cover
- Easy to wash and dry
OVERALL RATING: 8.9 out of 10
The Quilted Fitted Mattress Pad from Utopia Bedding is an inexpensive way to add a little padding and to keep cool at night. Don’t be fooled by the low price, though; this is not just another cheap knockoff.
The padding is fairly thin, so it is not going to convert that hard bed of yours into a plush, comfy one. What it will do is to create a layer between you and the bed and help you sleep cooler.
Use it over the top of your foam padding to help reduce heat buildup or use it as an extra layer of protection for your bed itself.
The cover also looks pretty good. It fits onto your bed like a fitted sheet and won’t slip off at night.
This does score points for being easy to wash and dry.
Hypoallergenic Quilted Stretch-to-Fit Mattress Pad By Hanna Kay
- Poly-cotton blend
- 10 Year Shield Guarantee
OVERALL RATING: 8.8 out of 10
This mattress pad scores big points in affordability. It is inexpensive and does provide some padding for your bed. In terms of comfort, it won’t make a huge difference to the firmness of your bed.
Where it does shine is in reducing heat transfer from foam padding. The poly-cotton blend in the cover is more breathable than one made of 100% polyester would be.
It fits the bed well, and the cover stays in place, without any wrinkling. The skirt is deep and stretches to fit up to a 16” depth. It will stay in place, even with very active sleepers.
The cover stands up well to washing and drying and does a good job of protecting your mattress. The company offers a 10-year warranty on this product which, considering the price, is pretty good.
Overall, this shapes up well and is a good budget-friendly option to try.
Web Linens Fully Reversible (Double Life)-1″ Down Alternative Mattress Pad
- Down Alternative
- Soft cover with sturdy stitching
OVERALL RATING: 8.6 out of 10
The Fully Reversible Down Alternative Mattress pad by Web Linens is strapped onto the bed, making installation quick and easy. You can quickly and easily rotate or flip the pad to ensure that it wears evenly.
The microfiber cover is exceptionally soft and has been well-stitched. It will not fall apart after the first few washes.
Be warned, when you take it out of the packaging, look for the instructions and follow them as closely as possible. Before using it for the first time, it needs to be aired for at least a day to get back into shape. Alternatively, it can be placed in the drier with a couple of tennis balls to fluff it up.
It offers a nice bit of padding and provides a decent barrier between you and your mattress. Used in conjunction with a memory foam topper, this makes a firm bed a whole lot more comfortable.
Topper vs. Pad vs. Protector vs. Encasement
Now, the truth is that there is an ongoing confusion amongst customers as to the actual difference between toppers, pads, encasements, and protectors. That's why we've decided to have a quick look at all of them and help you understand how they compare.
This is usually a more expensive and thicker version of the regular mattress pad. It's also generally more comfortable. It's likely that you might have tried those before and disliked them. However, contemporary technology allowed manufacturers to enhance their overall quality significantly and you would be sorry not to take a second look.
The mattress pad is usually more affordable and it's a thinner version of the topper. While they don't bring the same amount of comfort, they do bring a lot of additional features that many of the toppers don't, including precise heating and cooling features. Some people are going to prefer a pad while others – a topper and it's true that there are quite a lot of different ones designed to fit the myriad of personal preferences.
The protector is something entirely different. They are usually used to protect the sleeping items from issues such as allergic reactions or bedwetting, for example. These features, however, could easily be added in a topper or a pad so you wouldn't need an additional purchase.
This, on the other hand, is usually designed to provide you with the ultimate protection against bed bugs and are quite commonly used in hotels – as you might actually suggest. With this in mind, if you’ve had issues with bedbugs, for instance, you might truly take a look at these solutions for further information and also for added protection. They are quite different and distinct from the regular pad or topper.
Types of Mattress Pads
According to the buying behavior of customers, these toppers are undoubtedly amongst the most popular ones on the market. Memory foam is a conveniently crafted material which is designed to contour your body shape carefully and to memorize it conveniently.
The best thing about it is that it reduces the noise transmission from your partner and that it’s particularly durable. The product also allows the creation of pads in a range of different densities which is something quite convenient.
On the offside, we have the poor and questionable temperature control (here are some cooling tips) as well as the strong off-gassing smell when it’s new.
Cooling gel pads are particularly convenient, especially for those that sleep hot or suffer from night sweats. However, they are also rather expensive. Some are using an actual liquid system while others use existing fans to blow cold air up through your actual bed. As you may suggest, this brings an incredibly comfortable sleeping sensation and it allows you the ultimate temperature control.
- The mattress’s temperature is flawlessly controlled
- The sensation is amazing
- They are prone to causing a lot of complications
- They are rather expensive
When it comes to pillow top mattress toppers, you ought to know that the kind is a bit less firm and thicker in comparison to other counterparts. This is also why they are a lot less expensive in comparison. With this in mind, it’s also true that they deliver an enhanced sleeping sensation due to the ergonomic design. With this in mind, it might be a good idea for you to take a look at those and try one for yourself before going any further.
- They are very comfortable
- They are perfect for hip pain treatment
- They offer a range of different patterns
- They are not as thick
- They are usually a lot less firm
Toppers of the kind are most commonly made out of natural latex. This is an eco-friendly and naturally sourced material which is definitely designed to be the best when it comes to support, durability and comfort. They are free of any synthetic materials as well.
- It provides splendid support and it helps you ease the pain
- It is incredibly durable
- It’s free of toxins and it’s eco-friendly
- It’s more expensive
- It’s not suited for people with latex allergies
It’s also important to note that there are quite a lot of additional materials that you can easily take advantage of if you are looking for something far more specific. Feather and fiber are common choices but the most common one out of the big four is the topper made out of bamboo. They are known to be very gentle and particularly comfortable, giving you the sensation that you’re sleeping on a cloud.
On the other hand, if you prefer something a bit harder regarding sleeping feeling, you can also check out those which are made out of fiber or wool. The latter are characterized with their overall breathability which is going to help you sleep well through the night without waking up sweating in the middle of the night.
Buying Considerations For A Topper
Obviously, the size of your mattress topper is another crucial consideration that you'd have to account for. Of course, the size of your bed should consistently linger through your mind when you are considering purchasing a bed pad.
There are a few different sizes that you would be able to find toppers in – these include king, full, queen, and twin sizes.
For this exact reason, you will need to know the exact size of your own bed as well as the size of your mattress if you are going to be securing the perfect fit. If you purchase a smaller or a larger bed topper, this is going to make your entire bed feel a bit uneven.
Pay attention to this as it is something quite important and you’d certainly have to account for it.
The thickness of your mattress is another important and quite paramount characteristic that you would have to account for. This is undoubtedly something very important. Your mattress topper should be thick enough – that's just it. You should pay special attention to this particular consideration if you are to make a good call.
According to some experts, memory foam, as well as latex mattress pads, usually provide the best range when it comes to thickness. It's also worth noting, however, that every single thickness is best for a certain issue, so that's something you ought to account for.
The thickness will usually range between 1 and 5 inches. Your current condition of the mattress is likely to be a decisive factor when you choose the thickness of the pad. The general rule of thumb is that mattress pads which are thicker are appropriate for softer beds and the other way around. Basically, your topper should compensate the attributes that your mattress is lacking in.
Therefore, if you need a firmer appeal and your mattress can't provide it, go for a firmer topper. The opposite is also true. Studies conducted in Spain revealed that usually, a 2-inch thickness is perfect if your mattress is in a proper condition.
Firm or Soft
This is a debate which is definitely going to be raging on and on for an entire eternity. However, there is one simple truth here – it all depends on what you want and what works best for you.
Firmness is the characteristic which is going to be supporting your back. On the other hand, softness is what’s going to determine the contouring of your body. Each one of those is important for addressing back pain and other conditions. Of course, there are quite a few things that you might want to take into consideration when it comes to it.
It is usually considered that back sleepers can benefit more from a firmer mattress while side sleepers would need something softer. Stomach sleepers, on the other hand, would need something which is a comfortable blend and meets them in the middle. Of course, a lot of us combine all of the above and prefer different sleeping positions through the night. Therefore, your individuality is likely to determine this particular consideration.
However, if you have a certain medical condition related to your spinal alignment such as a slipped disc, for instance, you should definitely consider something which is rather firmer and has a density rating which is higher. A baby mattress topper, for example, should be a bit firmer, in order to prevent any spinal malformations early on. On the other hand, if you have a college kid, you can easily use a mid-range firmness to promote different sleeping positions.
Are Tempurpedic models Worth it?
There are a few key considerations which are worth taking into account when determining whether a Tempurpedic mattress topper is a worthy investment. Right off the bat, you ought to know that they take advantage of firm foam which is going to bring a serious support for your back. You wouldn’t have to worry about replacing the unit for a few years because they are rather reliable. They will also enhance and prolong the overall lifespan of your mattress.
At the same time, they are known to relieve the stress on different pressure points conveniently and without any hassle. This is going to quickly get rid of different sleeping related issues and ailments. You can rest assured that the Tempurpedic mattress toppers are perfect for back sleepers and they are also fairly appropriate for side and belly sleepers as well.
All in all, it is safe to determine that the products are truly worth the asking price and you are unlikely to go wrong with a mattress of the kind.
To conclude, the choice of a mattress topper is obviously going to be predicated on a myriad of different factors, each one of which is quite substantial.
Ultimately, though, you would have the last word. It is up to your personal preferences to make sure that you get a solution which is appropriate and which is going to accommodate your sleeping habits.
We've walked you through a few different products and we've tried to keep things versatile to encompass the differentiated demand. Hopefully, you will find value in the above and it would help you make the right call without wasting a tremendous amount of time in the process.
Sources and References:
- Mattress pad test procedure – https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/16/1632.5
- Flamability Studies – https://www.cpsc.gov/Regulations-Laws–Standards/Rulemaking/Final-and-Proposed-Rules/Flammability-of-Mattresses-and-Mattress-Pads
Author: Jill Thompson
I've been self-employed for almost four years and I would not change it for anything! I believe that anyone can achieve their goals with the right attitude and determination.
I'm an avid traveler (25+ countries and counting) that loves to meet new people doing amazing things.
When I'm not researching for the Sleep Advisor, you can find me reading, running, traveling, golfing, or meditating.
I wish you the very best on your journey!