Casper has been a staple in the online mattress industry since 2014, making waves by listening to what their customers have to say and delivering improvements to their product.
Nolah is newer to the scene, boasting a cooling bed by including their proprietary AirFoam™. Additionally, the plush design offers excellent pressure relief for side sleepers who struggle with achy hips and shoulders.
Casper vs. Nolah takes a look at what makes each brand special. Who will win out? The rookie or the seasoned veteran? Before you make your final decision, head over to our full reviews here:
Quick Comparison: Casper vs. Nolah
SLEEPADVISOR10 or click the button below
- For every sleeping position and weight class
- More bounce for a foam bed
- Quick responsiveness
SLEEPADVISOR or click the button below
- Medium level firmness
- Good pressure relief
- Temperature neutral
Comparing Construction (Materials & Quality)
This bed stands at 11 inches tall, is delivered boxed, and is made with multiple layers of foam. It is covered in stylish cover newly designed in 2020.
- The top layer uses AirScape technology in cooling foam.
- The second layer is made up of transitional Zoned Support™ foam that is denser in the hips and provides a cushion around the shoulders and your lower body.
- The bottom layer, a dense polyfoam, supplies a durable foundation.
Another all-foam option, this brand is a 10-inch mattress vacuum sealed and shipped in a box. Its trendy cover is similar to its competitor’s in style but is made with Tencel™ that is specially designed to regulate heat.
- The top layer is 2 inches of cooling, Airfoam™, which is exactly what it sounds like—infused foam with a bunch of pockets of air to aid temperature regulation.
- The next layer provides a latex-like bounce on 1 inch of supportive, pressure-relieving foam.
- The base layer reinforces the comfort of the surface layers in its 7 inches of highly dense but breathable foam.
Comparing Firmness (Support & Feel)
Using our comfort scale, we rated both mattresses based on firmness. The higher the score, the firmer the mattress, with 10 at the top; the lower the score, the softer it is, with 1 being the lowest.
Casper comes in at 6, placing it in the medium category. Generally, we recommend medium mattresses for the most versatile sleep experience because it should provide a good amount of both support and comfort. Its Zoned Support™ layer is a plus for side sleepers, as it should promote better spine alignment.
Nolah scored a 5, still a medium but on the softer end. It was constructed with side and back sleepers in mind—the comforting layers should relieve pressure in all the right places. Exclusive stomach sleepers, especially those that are heavier, may find the slighter firmer mattress to be more supportive.
Comparing Sinkage and Bounce
Casper and Nolah both provide a gentle cradle. You should be supported while feeling like you are on the bed instead of sinking in it. Because both beds include memory-like materials, there should still be that signature contouring feeling, but Nolah’s responsive layers and Casper’s bouncier surface should provide slightly less sinkage for either option.
Casper’s bouncy foam may make repositioning slightly easier than on Nolah; however, neither bed should be too difficult to move around on throughout the night.
Comparing Motion Transfer
These competitors should both insulate movements and minimize middle-of-the-night disturbances brought about by pets, kids, or restless partners. All-foam beds tend to perform well in this area, and Casper and Nolah’s comfort layers and foam bases should stop motion transfer in its tracks.
Comparing Edge Support
The edge support can be crucial for those who share the bed with loved ones or those who like to sleep more on the side of the mattress. Casper outperforms in this category compared to bed-in-a-box competitors, giving slight compression but still allowing full use of the bed’s surface.
Do not worry too much about bottoming out on the edge of Nolah, either. Although its performance is more average in this area, you should still feel secure while laying on the side.
Casper vs. Nolah Compared Side-by-Side
|Materials||Polyfoams, comfort foams, high-density memory foam||Polyfoams and Airfoam™|
|Cooling||Open-cell top layer with memory foam placed deeper in mattress||Airfoam™ technology and Tencel™ cover|
|Sinkage||Gentle cradle||Gentle Cradle|
|Trial Period||100 nights||120 nights|
|Adjustable Base Compatible||Yes||Yes|
|Shipping||Ships within the US, Canada, Germany, Austria, Switzerland, and the UK; In-Home delivery is available for certain locations||Ships for free to the contiguous United States.|
|Made in the USA||Mattress built in US, cover made in Mexico||Yes|
|Size||Casper Price (w/o discount)||Nolah Price (w/o discount)|
Should I Buy Casper or Nolah?
Both beds are all-foam and delivered in a box, but they have some differences in some of the features and feel. Here are some highlights that may help you decide which brand is right for your sleep preferences.
We Would Recommend Buying Casper if You are Looking for:
- Support for combination sleepers. Its Zoned Support™ layer should give relief in the lumbar area and shoulders, and its medium firmness should be comfortable and supportive for the average back, side, and stomach sleeper.
- Bouncier memory foam. Using open-cell technology, it is bouncier than your average all-foam bed, great for bedroom activities and repositioning.
- A versatile sleeping surface for couples. Scoring a medium on the firmness scale bodes well for couples with differing sleep preferences, and its above-average edge support means there is more bed to share.
We Would Recommend Buying Nolah if You are Looking for:
- Extra comfort for side sleepers. A softer surface should soften those pressure points that side sleepers experience in the hips and shoulders.
- A cooler rest. Its 2-inch Airfoam™ layer and latex-like foam should provide breathability and lessen the risk of overheating.
- Lightweight Sleeper Options. Smaller body types often aren’t heavy enough to sink through and activate firmer models. This plush design offers a softer alternative to provide soothing relief and a comfortable night’s sleep.
So are you going with the more versatile, bouncy sleeping surface of Casper? Or perhaps Nolah that is geared toward providing comfort in the hips and shoulders that many side sleepers desperately need? Its all up to you, but feel comforted knowing that both offer a decent trial period; if you think you made the wrong choice, you will have plenty of time to make a return.
If you need some more information before pulling the trigger, read our in-depth reviews where we chat about the specifics of each brand more extensively. Or you can take a look at our top beds for 2023 right here.