Best Casper Mattress Alternatives in 2023

*Disclaimer: The Casper Element is no longer available. 

If you love Casper mattresses but are looking for an alternative– perhaps one with a lower price point, a different firmness level, or a longer warranty– the list of comparable mattresses might seem overwhelming.

That’s why we've created this comprehensive guide, comparing and contrasting various alternatives to Casper mattresses. We’ve grouped those that are most similar so you can easily compare and contrast each mattress’s materials, construction, feel, cooling ability, price, trial, and warranty. We’ll also answer your frequently asked questions about these mattresses so that by the end of this guide, you’ll have a clear understanding of whether or not Casper is the right mattress for you.

Both the Casper and WinkBed are bed-in-a-box mattresses, but the Casper is a foam mattress and the WinkBed is a hybrid.

The Casper is made up of three foam layers. First, there’s the AirScape™ foam layer, which creates some bounce and breathability. Second, there’s the Zoned Support™ layer, a firmer foam layer that helps support the hips. The final layer is a unit of dense foam at the base.

The Winkbed consists of a Tencel© cover quilted to 2 inches of gel foam, followed by 2-inch thick Euro top made with gel-infused foam and an innerspring layer with zoned support. This innerspring layer gives the bed some bounce and breathability that an all-foam mattress won’t have.

While all the foams in the Casper are CertiPUR-US® certified to ensure you’re getting a quality and safe product, the WinkBed is slightly more eco-friendly, as it has a Tencel© cover, which is made from eucalyptus trees and is OEKO-TEX® Standard 100-certified. This certification means that it is free of any harmful substances.

The Casper feels like a medium-firm mattress, and rates as a 6 out of 10 on our mattress firmness scale. This means that it should work for a wide range of sleepers. When you press into the top of the mattress, it feels soft and cool to the touch, and if you keep pressing down or put your full weight onto the mattress, you’ll feel the next layer of more supportive foam slowly conform to the shape of your body. The Casper is a great bed for somebody who loves that classic “sinking in” feeling of a memory foam mattress, but doesn’t want to get too hot at night.

The Winkbed feels immediately different. To start, it comes in varying firmness levels: Soft (4.5 out of 10), Luxury Firm (6.5), and Firm (7.5). If you’re a side sleeper or weigh under 130 pounds, the Soft should provide excellent pressure relief and enough support, whereas heavier sleepers or those who sleep on their backs or stomachs should enjoy the Luxury Firm or Firm.

When you lie on the mattress, you’ll initially notice the contouring foam of the Euro top, but unlike the Casper, you’ll then notice the bounce and support of the innerspring layer. While both beds take measures to curb motion transfer, Casper has the edge over WinkBed because it’s an all-foam construction, whereas the WinkBed may produce slightly more motion transfer because of it’s innerspring layer.

Both beds make a point to address the issue of keeping you cool at night in their design, however, the WinkBed just does it better. This is because the Casper is an all-foam mattress, and even though their top layer of foam is designed to keep things cool, the WinkBed’s innerspring layer allows for more airflow. It also has a Tencel© cover, which is designed to be cooling and moisture-wicking for hot sleepers.

The price of each bed will depend on what size you’re getting. Unless you’re getting a Twin, the WinkBed is more expensive than the Casper. For example, a Queen Casper mattress will cost you 1,295 dollars, whereas a Queen WinkBed will cost 1,799 dollars.

The Casper comes with a 100-night trial period and a 10-year limited warranty. This includes free returns if you decide you don’t like it. WinkBed offers a 120-night trial period as well as a lifetime limited warranty. This also includes returns free of charge.

Read our full WinkBed mattress review to decide if it's best for you or shop the WinkBed mattress now. 

Both of these are hybrid mattresses, which means they have a layer of innerspring coils along with foam layers.

The Casper Wave Hybrid includes a layer of AirScape™ poly foam to relieve pressure and keep sleepers cool. This is followed by a layer of AirScape™ latex foam, which is firmer and bouncier. Next, is a third layer of AirScape™ memory foam that’s designed to contour to and support the body. Below this is a 1.5 inch layer of poly foam, which features gel pods under the waist and lower back areas to keep the spine in alignment. Lastly, the base is a 7-inch layer of durable pocket coil springs. The Casper Wave Hybrid’s cover is made of recycled polyester, upcycled cotton, rayon, and lycra.

The Saatva’s construction is a little less complex. There is a foam pillow top layer, followed by a lumbar support area designed to relieve back tension. Below the foam transition layer is the first layer of innerspring coils, which are also zoned to support the back. Further down is a second innerspring unit containing 7-inch steel hour-glass shaped support coils, which help prevent sagging and provide support. The edges are also encased in a sturdy, thick foam for increased edge support. The Saatva’s cover is made from natural cotton that is breathable. And treated for anti-microbial properties.

Both mattresses feature eco-friendly certifications, but the Saatva is slightly more environmentally conscious. This is because it uses upcycled steel for its coils, contains natural cotton, and has CertiPUR-US® and GOTS certifications.

The Casper Wave Hybrid is a bed-in-a-box product, which means it comes to your door compressed in a box. Once it decompresses, the bed itself will feel medium-firm, rating at a 6 out of 10 on our mattress firmness scale. Its cover is soft, breathable, and cooling, and when you lie down, you should notice the “sinking in” feeling of the top foam layers, but the coils will make it easy enough to move around on the bed and not feel stuck.

The Saatva is not a bed-in-a-box, meaning it will be delivered to your door (with free white glove delivery) fully decompressed and ready to sleep on. It comes in three firmness options: Plush Soft (4 out of 10), Luxury Firm (6.5), and Firm (8). For this reason, the Saatva is going to be better for those who want some additional customization to the feel of their mattress.

The Casper Wave Hybrid is also more contouring and pressure-relieving than the Saatva (unless you get the softest Saatva model), whereas the Saatva is slightly better for back support.

Both of these mattresses are hybrids, which means they’ll provide more airflow and sleep cooler than most beds. The Casper Wave Hybrid goes above and beyond, though, by including cooling gel foam, a layer of latex foam, and perforated memory foam throughout. This makes it the better mattress for those who sleep especially hot.

The Casper Wave Hybrid is significantly more expensive than the Saatva Classic. For a Queen size, it costs almost 1,000 dollars more.

The Casper comes with a 100-day trial period, a 10 year-limited warranty, and returns at no charge.

The Saatva Classic has a 365-night sleep trial, a lifetime warranty, and also offers returns at no charge. Saatva also offers complementary white glove delivery, which means they’ll deliver your new mattress, set it up, and remove your old mattress for free.

Read our full Saatva mattress review to decide if it's best for you or shop the Saatva Classic mattress now. 

Both of these mattresses are hybrids. The Casper Nova consists of four layers. The first layer is proprietary AirScape™ foam with “puff fabric” that cradles the body. This layer is perforated to not trap heat. Beneath that is a layer of soft AirScape™ foam, which is also perforated for cooling. It has three zones that are softer under the shoulders and firmer under the hips, waist, and low back to keep the spine in proper alignment. Below this is a layer of memory foam with seven support zones, and finally, there is a unit of innerspring coils for support, bounce, and cooling.

All of the foams in the Casper Nova are CertiPUR-US® certified, which means that they’ve passed rigorous safety testing around the use of ozone-depleting chemicals and are low in emissions for indoor air quality. The bed’s cover is eco-friendly and features recycled polyester and upcycled cotton, rayon, and lycra. The bed also contains up to 70 recycled bottles.

The Helix Sunset has a top layer of memory foam for contouring and pressure relief. Benearth this is a unit of Helix Dynamic Foam, which is soft, cushioning, and provides some ergonomic support. This is followed by a support layer of hundreds of individually-wrapped coils, which adds bounce and cooling to the bed. The base features DuraDense Foam, a poly foam that supports the mattress.

The Helix Sunset’s cover is made from 100 percent polyester and is not as eco-friendly as the Casper Nova’s, though all of the foams in this mattress are CertiPUR-US® certified.

Both of these mattresses are designed to feel soft and “cloud-like.” We don’t recommend either for those who prefer a firm mattress, sleep on their stomachs, or for heavier sleepers.

That said, the Casper feels slightly softer than the Helix Sunset, rating at a 5 out of 10 for firmness, whereas the Helix Sunset is at 5.5. While this isn’t a huge difference in firmness, these mattresses do feel different when it comes to motion isolation.

Since both of these hybrid beds include a layer of coils, they are both going to be somewhat bouncy – a good thing for changing positions and promoting airflow. However, the Casper Nova Hybrid is slightly better at isolating motion than the Helix Sunset, making it a better mattress for sensitive sleepers who share the bed.

Both are great choices for side sleepers, people with joint or back pain, hot sleepers, and lighter weight sleepers.

These two mattresses are designed with cooling in mind. The Casper Nova has tiny perforations throughout the first two layers of foam to let heat escape, and the Helix Sunset’s Soft Touch Design cover is extremely breathable. Both beds have innerspring layers with individually-wrapped coils, which deliver more airflow throughout the mattress.

Plus, you can upgrade either of these mattresses to have even more cooling features if sleeping hot is a major concern.

This might be the biggest difference between these two mattresses. While a Queen-sized Casper Nova costs 2,295 dollars, the same sized Helix Sunset costs just 1,249 dollars.

The Casper Nova comes with a 100-night trial period, free returns, and a 10-year limited warranty. Likewise, the Helix Sunset comes with a 100-night trial period, free returns, and a 10-year limited warranty.

Read our full Helix Sunset mattress review to decide if it's best for you or shop the Helix Sunset mattress now. 

Both the Casper Element and the Tuft & Needle are all-foam beds. The Element has two layers of foam. The top layer is made up of 2 inches of breathable AirScape™ comfort foam that promotes airflow for temperature regulation and is quick-responding, so moving around and re-positioning should be easy. The second layer is 8.5 inches of a durable base form that is firmer and more supportive.

The Tuft & Needle also has two layers of foam. The top layer is made up of 3 inches of T&N Adaptive® Foam, which is like a combination of memory foam and latex. This foam is both pressure-relieving and supportive. It also wicks away heat with graphite and is infused with cooling gel. The next layer is a base layer of seven-inch thick poly foam. This layer is much firmer than the top layer.

While both mattresses are similarly constructed, the Tuft & Needle is slightly more eco-friendly, with both a CertiPUR-US® and GREENGUARD Gold certification.

Both of these foam mattresses come in a box, so they’ll take some time to decompress and air out once you’ve unboxed them. After that, though, they have some slight differences in feel.

The Casper Element is a medium-firm mattress, rating at a 6 out of 10 on our mattress firmness scale, whereas the Tuft & Needle is slightly softer at a 5 out of 10. Even though they’re foam mattresses, neither of these beds should make you feel like you’re sinking too far into them, though they’ll still provide you with a good amount of pressure relief.

The Tuft & Needle will be slightly more responsive and bouncy, and with the Casper Element, you’ll get better motion isolation and edge support.

All the foams used in the Casper Element are open-celled, so they’ll promote airflow and prevent heat retention. The Tuft & Needle has included graphite and cooling gel in the top layer. Both mattresses should sleep cooler than many all-foam mattresses on the market, but if you sleep especially hot, neither will be the very coolest.

Both the Casper Element and Tuft & Needle are budget-friendly mattresses, with a Queen mattress costing 449 dollars and 695 dollars, respectively.

Both the Casper Element and Tuft & Needle offer a 100-day trial period, including no cost on returns, as well as a 10-year limited warranty.

Read our full Tuft & Needle mattress review to decide if it's best for you or shop the Tuft & Needle mattress now. 

There is no doubt that Casper makes a high quality bed-in-a-box mattress with simple delivery and easy setup, but that doesn’t necessarily mean it will be the right mattress for you. When considering whether to buy a Casper or something else, you’ll want to keep in mind specific qualities like the price, firmness, trial, and warranty.

• Price: In general, Casper mattresses are on-par with other brands, though some models will be more expensive than others. A Queen-size Casper mattress, for example, will typically cost at least 1,000 dollars or even up to 2,300 dollars.
• Firmness: Casper mattresses tend to be medium-firm, or somewhere between a 5 or 6 out of 10 on the firmness rating scale. This is great for most people since a medium-firm mattress accommodates most sleeping positions and weights. However, for those who want a very soft or very firm mattress, it might be tough to find a Casper that fits the bill.
• Trial & Warranty: Casper offers a 100-night trial and a 10-year limited warranty. Some other mattress brands offer 365-night trials and lifetime warranties or something in between. If it’s important to you to have more time to try out your mattress and a longer warranty, you might be better off with a different mattress brand. Saatva, for example, is known for its excellent trial and warranty period.

Since there are different types of Casper mattresses, there are varying types of similar mattresses on the market. The Casper Original is comparable to a WinkBed Original. The Casper Wave Hybrid is most similar to the Saatva Classic. The Casper Nova Hybrid is similar to the Helix Sunset, and the Casper Element is similar to the Tuft & Needle.

The Casper mattress offered at Costco is called the “Casper Select” and is exclusively offered through Costco. It is similar to the original Casper in that both are made with foam and are designed for both support and pressure relief, though the Casper Select is a less-expensive alternative.

Casper mattresses tend to be medium-firm, which is a good middle ground for most sleepers. If you’re looking for something softer, though, you might try the Plush Soft model of the Saatva Original, the original Tuft & Needle, or the original Puffy mattress.

Like many mattress companies, Casper makes mattresses at various price points and levels of luxury. Their Element model is more basic and is also one of the most budget-friendly mattresses out there, costing less than 500 dollars for a Queen mattress. On the more luxurious end, though, is the Casper Wave Hybrid, which includes more layers and more expensive materials. That mattress is priced at 2,895 dollars for a Queen.