Our Nolah vs. Alexander Signature Hybrid Bed Comparison for 2020

Transparency Disclosure – We may receive a referral fee (at no additional cost to the buyer) for products purchased through the links on our site or other applicable pages. To learn more, please read our full disclosure page here. We also encourage you to read about how we may research and/or test Products here.

Can’t decide between a hybrid or an all-foam bed?

This Alexander and Nolah comparison will break down the construction of these two types of products and how they offer different styles of support.

Nest Bedding believes good sleep should last forever and offers a lifetime comfort guarantee to prove it. Nolah is dedicated to giving back to the environment and offers a wildlife sponsorship program to go along with your mattress purchase. While these beds may be very different, these two companies do agree on creating comfortable sleep experiences that cater to their customers’ needs.

For more information on how the features these items have to offer, read through our in-depth reviews that take a closer look at each bed:

Quick Comparison: Alexander Signature Hybrid and Nolah

the alexander signature hybrid small image
Use Coupon Code
SLEEPADVISOR8 or click the button below
  • Enhanced cooling properties
  • Deep hug experience
  • High quality foam and coils
small product image of Nolah
Use Coupon Code
SLEEPADVISOR or click the button below
  • Medium level firmness
  • Good pressure relief
  • Temperature neutral

Comparing Construction (Materials & Quality)

Alexander Signature Hybrid Construction

This is a foam and coil hybrid that is compressed, boxed, and shipped to your door.

This 13-inch mattress features a polyester and cotton blended cover with Thermic Phase Change technology and Gel-Infused Memory Foam quilted into it to promote a cooler sleep experience.

updated alexander signature hybrid layer structure
  • The top layer is a 3-inch TitanChil Endurance Foam. This material should prevent overheating and provide deep sinkage for pressure relief.
  • The next layer holds a 1-inch SmartFlow Support Foam. This material is aerated to promote airflow.
  • The base layer is comprised of 8-inch Quantum Edge Pocketed Support Coils
  • Under that there is an inch of support foam to cushion coils.

Nolah Construction

This is an all-foam bed-in-a-box product.

The Viscose and polyester blended cover should feel soft and is designed to wick moisture away from the body to prevent overheating. The total height of this mattress is 10 inches.

Construction of Nolah bed
  • The top layer is Cooling Nolah AirFoam that is 2 inches thick. This memory material should prevent overheating and provide pressure relief.
  • The second layer contains 1 inch of Supportive High-Resilience Foam. The material in this level is meant to provide responsiveness and bounce for easy repositioning.
  • The base layer is made up of a 7-inch High-Density Base Foam. This should provide stability and support to the entire mattress.

Comparing Firmness (Support & Feel)

Each item has been placed on our comfort / firmness scale that uses a 1-10 system. Using this method, 1 should feel like you’re sleeping a cloud and 10 should feel like a sturdy rock bed.

Alexander’s Medium option comes in at a 5-6, making it a true Medium for lighter sleepers or perhaps a Medium-Firm for those who sink through the upper layers and rest against the firmer support layers. This company also provides a Plush version which comes in with a 2.5-3 and a Luxury Firm with an 8.5-9 rating.

The Nolah Original offers one comfort level, a Medium which we have ranked at 4.5. This is only slightly below a true Medium. Some sleepers may experience this as a Medium-Soft.

Those looking for a wider range of options will likely appreciate the Signature’s different comfort levels that are available. This should not completely take the all-foam out of the running, however, as its universal appeal should satisfy most shoppers.

Alexander should sleep cool thanks to the coil system, which is also designed to provide pressure relief that adapts to body weight and position. The Nolah is an all-foam construction but is meant to provide more bounce and cooling than traditional memory foam.

Firmness scale for Alexander Hybrid and Nolah bed

Comparing Sinkage and Bounce

This section offers some distinct differences in how these two items perform. The Alexander should provide a deep hug with plenty of supportive contouring. The all-foam should offer a gentle cradle while the Deep Supportive High-Resilience Foam is meant to promote pressure relief.

The Signature should provide more bounce than the Nolah, but this is to be expected given the hybrid versus all-foam construction. Both products should be easy to move and reposition in, Alexander because of the coils which should help to counteract the slower responding foams, and its competitor because of the firmer pushback provided by the base support.

Buyers who want to feel like they are sleeping “in” their bed will likely prefer the Hybrid. People who prefer to “float on top” should consider the Nolah.

Comparing Motion Transfer

Neither of these products should allow for very much motion transfer. Dense layers of foam and individually pocketed coils are designed to absorb and isolate energy to prevent disruptions from restless partners. If this is an important consideration for you, the Nolah may make a great choice as the Signature contains coils which may allow some transfer of movement.

Comparing Edge Support

Most shoppers may not consider this feature to be a dealbreaker when choosing a new and perfect bed. Those who want enhanced edge support may prefer the Quantum coil design of the Alexander. The Nolah does provide good support but may show more compression due to its all-foam construction.

Alexander Signature Hybrid and Nolah Compared Side-by-Side

FeaturesAlexander Signature HybridNolah
CoverPolyester and cotton blend, Gel-Infused Memory Foam and Thermic Phase Change fabric quilted in for temperature regulationViscose and polyester blend
MaterialsA combination of foam and coils including TitanChil Endurance Foam, Quantum Edge Pocketed Support Coils, SmartFlow Support FoamCooling AirFoam, Supportive High Resilience Foam, High-Density Base Foam
CoolingPocketed coils, aerated materials, copper, cooling gels, Thermic Phase Change fabricViscose moisture-wicking cover, cooling AirFoam
Motion TransferMinimalMinimal
Edge SupportExceptionalGood
SinkageDeep HugGentle Cradle
Bounce ModerateMinimal
WarrantyLifetime15 years
Trial Period100 nights120 nights
Adjustable Base CompatibleYesYes
ShippingFree in the contiguous United States, ships internationally, White Glove can be arranged through the companyFree in the contiguous United States
Made in the USAYesYes
SizeAlexander Signature Hybrid Price (w/o discount)Nolah Price (w/o discount)
Twin XL$899$699
Cali King$1,499$999
Split King (1 side only)$899N/A
Split King (both sides)$1,799N/A
Split Cali King (both sides)$1,799N/A

Should I Buy the Alexander Signature Hybrid or Nolah?

These two brands offer drastically different options that are likely to appeal to a variety of sleepers.

Hybrid fans might prefer the Signature while shoppers who like a memory foam feel should enjoy the Nolah. Differences in sinkage levels and cooling properties may help you make your decision, as well.

Read through our recommendations below to get an idea of who we think should consider each mattress.

We Would Recommend Buying Alexander if You are Looking for:

  • A hybrid feel. This item combines layers of foam with individually pocketed coils to provide solid support with a deep sinking comfort.
  • Multiple comfort options. Shoppers looking to personalize their comfort level can explore the Plush, Medium, and Luxury Firm options the company has made available for purchase.
  • Cooling technologies. Copper, gels, and phase changing technologies incorporated into the mattress and cover should regulate temperature and prevent overheating.

We Would Recommend Buying Nolah if You are Looking for:

  • An all-foam experience. If coils aren’t your bag, you may prefer this product and its all-foam construction that offers support and a gentle cradle so you shouldn’t ever feel “stuck.”
  • Pressure relief. Side sleepers, in particular, may be drawn to this mattress because of its slightly Softer than Medium comfort level. This feel should prevent too much pushback in the heavier areas like shoulders and hips that tend to press into the bed.
  • Environmental impact. A portion of every purchase is dedicated to sponsoring an endangered wildlife animal. Buyers may choose from a list of creatures to sponsor, including polar bears, penguins, and bald eagles.

Final Thoughts

If you’re looking for a luxury feel with a deep hug, excellent edge support, and multiple comfort options, you should consider adding Alexander to your shortlist. If a gentle cradle with minimal bounce, an affordable price point, and conservation efforts sound more like you, check out the Nolah for your mattress-buying needs.

For a deeper dive into both of these brands, be sure to read through our in-depth reviews to further decide which works best for you.

Sleep Advisor