Our Nolah vs. WinkBed Mattress Comparison for 2023

Transparency Disclosure – We may receive a referral fee for products purchased through the links on our site... Read More.

Considering an all-foam or innerspring mattress for your next purchase?

This Nolah vs. WinkBed comparison will look at Nolah’s all-foam product that provides excellent pressure relief for side sleepers and compares it to WinkBed’s foam and coil construction is built especially for you as soon as your order is placed.

Keep reading to see how these two products compare. Then check out our in-depth reviews for each product for a more comprehensive analysis of each one:

Quick Comparison: Nolah vs. WinkBed

small product image of Nolah
Use Coupon Code
SLEEPADVISOR or click the button below
  • Medium level firmness
  • Good pressure relief
  • Temperature neutral
medium product image of winkbeds
Use Coupon Code
SLEEPADVISOR300 or click the button below
  • Well distributed support
  • Reduces heat retention
  • Good for heavier individuals

Comparing Construction (Materials & Quality)

Nolah Construction

nolah original bed layers
  • The top layer contains a 2-inch thick Cooling Nolah AirFoam™. This material should remain temperature neutral even as it contours to the body.
  • The middle layer holds a 1-inch Supportive High-Resilience Foam. This section should provide bounce and durable support.
  • The bottom layer contains 7 inches of High-Density Base Foam that should provide a durable foundation for the upper comfort materials.

WinkBed Construction

This is a hybrid mattress featuring a combination of coils and foam.

The cover boasts a Tencel blend that should promote temperature regulation. We will focus on the construction of the Luxury Firm model, which stands 13.5 inches tall. Differences between the various comfort options will be noted below.

Winkbed Mattress Layer Construction
  • The first layer is a medium-firm Eurotop containing 2 inches of gel-infused Hypersoft foam. This material should provide pressure relief and temperature control. The Firmer and Softer versions of this bed feature pillow tops with slightly different feels to create the appropriate comfort levels.
  • The second layer contains a 2.5-inch SupportCell foam for extra pressure relief.
  • The innerspring layer holds 8-inch pocketed coils  featuring 5 support zones. This should allow for firmer support or gentle pressure relief where your body needs it most.
  • The base layer is made up of a 1-inch polyfoam that should help absorb some motion from the coils above, promoting motion control.

The company also offers a Plus version for sleepers with considerable weight concerns. The construction of the Plus model is somewhat different to accommodate these shoppers’ needs.

Comparing Firmness (Support & Feel)

Our comfort scale assigns rankings between 1 and 10 for each mattress to determine how each bed should feel. This system assumes that 1 is incredibly soft and 10 is very firm.

Nolah’s Original mattress features a 4.5 to 5 on this scale, making it a medium to medium-soft comfort level. This should work for most sleepers, though side sleepers may be particularly drawn to this softer level of comfort.

Lying on the Nolah, you should find the cover to be soft and cool to the touch. The materials should reshape easily, faster than a traditional memory foam material but perhaps slightly slower than latex.

WinkBed’s Luxury Firm sits at a 6.5, which should feel more like a medium-firm to most shoppers. This should be ideal for back sleepers and for people who like to sleep on their stomach who prefer a firmer comfort level. The company’s Softer model has earned a 4.5, the Firmer option holds a score of 7.5, and the Plus is ranked as an 8.

The cover should feel cool and stretchy. The materials should reform quickly to reduce body impressions that could leave you feeling “stuck” in the foam.

nolah and winkbed comfort levels

Comparing Sinkage and Bounce

Neither bed should allow for very much sinkage, instead offering a gentle cradle that contours to the body. Nolah should provide very minimal bounce, as its all-foam construction should dampen most movements. WinkBed should offer minimal bounce in the upper foam layers with a deeper bounce once the coils become activated.

Because WinkBed offers materials that are slightly quicker to respond, with more overall bounce, this product may be slightly more ideal for combination sleepers who move around frequently in their beds.

Comparing Motion Transfer

Both items should do very well to minimize motion transfer, helping to reduce sleep disruptions due to antsy pets or children. Shoppers with heightened concerns in this area may want to consider the Nolah, as the coil units inside the WinkBed may allow more motion to travel through the mattress than the all-foam bed should.

Comparing Edge Support

Nolah should offer good edge support that performs as-expected for an all-foam product. Some compression may be noticed when lying on the edge, though this does not usually concern most shoppers.

People who prefer to sleep along the edge of the bed may want to opt for the WinkBed, with its edge-to-edge coil construction that should enhance support around the perimeter.

Nolah vs. WinkBed Compared Side-by-Side

CoverTencel™Tencel fabric
MaterialsPolyfoam and AirFoam™Coils and foam
CoolingAirFoam™ and Tencel™Tencel, cooling gel, pocketed coils
Motion TransferMinimalMinimal
Edge SupportGood
SinkageGentle CradleGentle Cradle
BounceMinimalMinimal upper, moderate deeper
WarrantyLifetime warrantyLifetime warranty
Trial Period120 nights120 nights

OEKO-TEX® Standard 100 Class 1
Adjustable Base CompatibleYesYes
ShippingFree in the continental United StatesFree within the continental United States
Made in the USAYesYes
SizeNolah Price (w/o discount)WinkBed Price (w/o discount)
Twin XL$899$1,249
Cali King$1,349$2,049

Should I Buy Nolah or WinkBed?

Still torn between the benefits of an all-foam or innerspring mattress? Let’s take a look at our recommendations to find out who each product should best work for.

We Would Recommend Buying Nolah if You are Looking for:

  • Cooling capabilities. Nolah's proprietary AirFoam™ and Tencel™ cover keeps the sleeper cool while providing enough pressure relief and comfort.
  • All-foam comfort. This mattress should provide gentle pressure relief that contours to the body. Buyers should notice minimal bounce and enhanced motion control.
  • A medium feel. This mattress features a medium to medium-soft comfort level that should suit people of most position preferences.

We Would Recommend Buying WinkBed if You are Looking for:

  • A product made-to-order. The company will build your new bed when you order it. Your mattress will never be held in a factory or warehouse so you’ll know you’re getting a freshly made bed built just for you.
  • An innerspring experience. This product should provide plenty of bounce with enhanced edge support. Sleepers should notice solid support that is enhanced the 5-zone design on the coil unit.
  • Multiple comfort options. Softer, Luxury Firm, and Firmer comfort options are available for purchase. The company also offers a Plus model for shoppers with more considerable weight concerns.

Final Thoughts

Both companies offer quality products that should provide a great night’s sleep. Shoppers who prefer minimal bounce, enhanced motion control, a medium feel, and pressure relief should opt for the all-foam Nolah. WinkBed should work well for people searching for moderate bounce, enhanced edge support, multiple comfort options, and a solid coil experience.

Be sure to read through our individual in-depth reviews for each item to get a closer look at their features and strengths.

Katie Simpson
Sleep Advisor