Our Casper Original vs. Tempur-Pedic Comparison for 2023

Transparency Disclosure – We may receive a referral fee for products purchased through the links on our site... Read More.

Casper and Tempur-Pedic are two of the pioneers in the bed-in-the-box industry. Their experience and dedication to making easily accessible and quality mattresses is evident in the mattresses that they both produce. However, is one of these veterans better than the other when it comes to providing you with an optimal night’s rest?

In this Casper vs. Tempur-Pedic comparison, we break down how these two mattresses compare and contrast across a variety of categories so you can decide which is right for you. Will it be the traditional slow-sinking sensation of Tempur-Pedic or the Zoned Support of the Casper?

Quick Comparison: Casper vs. Tempur-Pedic

Casper Original Product Image
Check pricing and availability by clicking the button below
  • Breathable AirScape™
  • Responsive feel
  • 100-night trial period
  • Casper Review
Product image of Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Cloud Compressed Mattress
Check pricing and availability by clicking the button below

Watch Our Video Review of Casper vs. Tempur-Pedic

Who I’d Recommend the Casper For

  • People who need enhanced spinal support – The middle layer of the Casper is made up of ergonomically-zoned memory foam. That means it contains three zones that provide soft support around the shoulders, while giving enhanced support around the hips, stomach, and back.

  • Couples – The Casper’s medium-firm feel is appealing to a wide range of body types and sleep positions. This makes it good for couples who may have different wants and needs in their mattresses.

  • All-foam fans who sleep hot – Although all-foam mattresses are typically hotter than other bed types, the Casper uses their perforated proprietary AirScape™ foam at the top layer to provide cooling relief.

Who I’d Recommend the Tempur-Pedic For

  • Pressure relief seekers – All Tempur-Pedic models offer great relief seekers. However, upgraded models of the Tempur-Pedic are enhanced with proprietary materials that enhance the pressure relief capabilities even more.

  • Consumers shopping for affordable luxury – The Tempur-Pedic offers a host of beneficial features, as well as quality materials. Therefore, these mattresses may be more expensive than some of their competitors, but given the solid construction that provides cooling, pressure relief, and support we think these beds are still a good deal.

  • Folks with specific sleep needs – Those who are looking for features such as advanced pressure relief and cooling will enjoy being able to select a Tempur-Pedic option that matches their needs.

Comparing Casper vs Tempur-Pedic: Top Similarities

  • Excellent motion isolation – The all-foam models of the Casper and Tempur-Pedic models provide excellent motion isolation. This makes both of these beds a great choice for couples and other co-sleepers.
  • Great for back sleepers – The medium-firmness of both of these beds will likely appeal to back sleepers. The Casper and the Tempur-Pedic both provide exceptional support around the hips which will help with spinal alignment and pressure relief.
  • Memory foam design – Both the Casper and all Tempur-Pedic models are made entirely of foam. While the exact feel they provide may differ slightly, all-foam fans should enjoy either construction.

Comparing Casper vs Tempur-Pedic: Key Differences

  • Price – Although both mattresses are a good value for their price, the Tempur-Pedic is considerably more expensive. Given that the mattresses have many similarities including the same length of warranty, you may want to take this into consideration.
  • Natural materials – Whereas Tempur-Pedic uses a mix of natural and synthetic materials, Casper does not use any natural materials in their mattresses. This may give those who are eco-conscious pause when considering a Casper.
  • Support – Both beds provide great support, but the Casper uses specific zones to target areas of the body that may need more or less support, whereas the Tempur-Pedic takes a more all-over approach to support.

Comparing Firmness, Support & Feel

Firmness

We rate firmness on a scale from 1 to 10, with one being soft as a cloud. The Casper Original is rated a 6 out of 10 which means that it has a medium-firm feel that should work great for a variety of sleeping situations.

Most Tempur-Pedic options come in a variety of firmness levels, giving you the option to choose what suits you best. However, the TEMPUR-Cloud® bed, Tempur-Pedic’s most popular model comes in at a 6.5 on the firmness scale which should also make it appealing to the masses. Most sleepers won’t have to worry about either of these mattresses being too soft or hard.

firmness scale for 6 and 6.5

Support

Tempur-Pedic isn’t shy when it comes to providing support. Each of their beds are offered in either all-foam or hybrid. Therefore, if you are someone who wants extra support, you will probably want to check out a hybrid as they generally offer more when it comes to support. Although the Casper is an all-foam mattress, you can still count on it to be supportive. This is due in large part to the Casper’s zoning layer that provides extra support around heavier parts of the body.

Feel

The top of the Casper is soft and cool-to-the touch, and as you press down you should notice how quickly the foam layers respond. As you lie down, you will be nestled in the top foam layer as the lower layer of memory foam envelops you in a full-body hug. The Tempur-Pedic has an appealingly soft cover, and the memory foam make-up allows you to quickly sink deep into this bed which will help relieve pressure. You should feel more of the traditional slow-sinking sensation that usually accompanies memory foam beds with Tempur-Pedic, while the Casper offers a bouncier, more responsive feel.

Comparing Sinkage and Bounce

If you desire sinking deep into your mattress to snuggle in for the evening, you should definitely check out the Tempur-Pedic as its memory foam offers deep sinkage. If you choose an all-foam Tempur-Pedic option, you probably will not experience a great deal of bounce. However, those who reposition a lot or sexually-active couples can opt for one of Tempur-Pedic’s hybrid models for more bounce. The Casper

Original is an all-foam mattress, and while you will likely never feel stuck, you also probably won’t experience a lot of bounce. However, similar to Tempur-Pedic, if you like the Casper Original but prefer more bounce, you can choose one of Casper’s hybrid models.

Comparing Motion Transfer

Although the Casper Original and the Tempur-Pedic foam-options don’t have a lot of bounce, they both more than make up for it when it comes to motion isolation. Both of these beds are shining stars when it comes to keeping motion from transferring across the bed. Even if you have a restless sleep mate, the foam layers of both of these beds will keep the disturbances from their twists and turns to their side of the bed. This makes both the Casper and Tempur-Pedic exceptional choices for couples and other co-sleepers.

Comparing Cooling

If you’re constantly turning down the A/C at night, a mattress that helps keep you cool is definitely something you will want to consider. Fortunately, both the Casper Original and the Tempur-Pedic have implemented features that promote body temperature regulation. Foam doesn’t always sleep cool because its dense nature doesn’t allow for much airflow. However, Casper’s AirSpace® foam allows for air to move through it and in turn keep sleepers cool. Tempur-Pedic has a collection of beds that specifically focus on keeping you cool, but even their basic all-foam offering has cooling capacities that help dissipate body heat.

Comparing Construction (Materials & Quality)

Casper Original Construction

At 11 inches tall, the Casper Original consists of three distinct layers and is covered in a soft polyester cover.

original Casper bed layers image graphics
  • The first foam layer is made up of Casper’s perforated proprietary cooling foam called AirScape™. This provides the mattress a little bounce and also helps dissipate heat and promote airflow.
  • The second layer is constructed with 2 inches of Zoned Support™. This innovative layer consists of memory foam that is specifically positioned to offer firmer support in the area where a sleeper’s hips are located and is softer around the shoulders and legs which benefit from extra pressure relief.
  • The base layer of this mattress consists of a durable, supportive, and denser foam that provides the foundation of the Casper mattress.

The Casper Original is also available in a hybrid model with a layer of coils in addition to the foam comfort layers.

Tempur-Pedic Construction

Consisting of three layers, the TEMPUR-Cloud® has a 10-inch high profile. The mattress has a moisture-wicking and breathable Stretch Cover. All Tempur-Pedic models, including the TEMPUR-Cloud®, have all-foam and hybrid options. This section will break down the materials and construction of the all-foam version of their base model, the TEMPUR-Cloud® mattress.

Mattress Construction of TEMPUR-Cloud
  • The TEMPUR® comfort layer is directly under the Stretch Cover that contains soft and responsive TEMPUR® material.
  • The TEMPUR® support layer is thicker and firmer than the comfort layer, and it provides all-over pressure relief throughout their body.
  • The base layer is the thickest of all the sections. The bottom of the mattress will provide support and spinal alignment.

All of Tempur-Pedic’s mattresses are offered in all-foam and hybrid options.

Comparing Company Policies & Price

  • Warranty – Both Casper and Tempur-Pedic provide 10-year warranties on their mattresses.
  • Shipping – Tempur-Pedic offers free shipping within the contiguous United States, and shipping is available to Alaska, Hawaii and other U.S. territories for an additional fee (white glove delivery is not available for the Tempur-Cloud®, but it is included for all other models. You will receive free shipping if you live in America or Canada when you order a Casper mattress. If you’d prefer to leave your mattress set-up to the professionals, Casper will provide this for an additional fee.
  • Trial Period – Casper gives you 100 nights to try out your mattress. With Tempur-Pedic, you will have to make your decision about 10 days sooner as they only provide a 90-night trial.
  • Returns – With both mattresses, you are required to try them for at least 30 days. If after that time, you are not satisfied with your mattress you can return it for a full refund
  • Price – Although the TEMPUR-Cloud® is Tempur-Pedic’s base model, it is still an expensive mattress. You should expect to pay almost twice as much for some sizes if you opt for the Tempur-Pedic mattress.
FeaturesCasperTempur-Pedic
Height11”10”
CoverPolyester fabricMoisture-wicking and breathable
360 degree cover
MaterialsPerforated AirScape™ foam, Memory foamProprietary TEMPUR® foam
CoolingPerforated AirScape™ foamVarious cooling capabilities
Firmness6/106.5/10
SupportGreatGreat
Motion TransferMinimalMinimal
Edge SupportGoodGood
SinkageContouring HugGentle cradle
BounceMinimalMinimal
Warranty10 years10 years
Trial Period100 nights90 nights
CertificationsCertiPUR-US®CertiPUR-US®
Adjustable Base CompatibleYesYes
ShippingShips free to U.S. and Canada.
Optional White Glove Delivery available for additional fee
Ships to the contiguous U.S. for free.
Ships to Alaska, Hawaii, Puerto Rico
Made in the USAYesYes
Read Full ReviewCasper Mattress ReviewTempur-Pedic Review
Shop NowCasper MattressTempur-Pedic Mattress

Casper vs. Tempur-Pedic Compared Side-by-Side

SizeCasper Price (w/o discount)Tempur-Pedic Price (w/o discount)
Twin$895$1,699
Twin XL$995$1,699
Full$1,195$1,899
Queen$1,295$1,999
King$1,695$2,399
Cali King$1,695$2,399
Split KingN/A$3,398
Split Cali KingN/AN/A

Final Thoughts

There are many reasons to love both the Casper and Tempur-Pedic: Both brands offer supportive, comfortable, and cooling all-foam mattresses. However, the most obvious difference between the two is the price. Tempur-Pedic’s pricing pushes it closer to the luxury bed range, but it offers an exceptional product that is likely to appeal to many average and lightweight individuals.

Casper provides a fantastic mattress as well, but for less. In other words, you will definitely have a little more money in your pocket if you decide to go with the Casper. Co-sleepers and those searching for prime-time pressure relief can’t really go wrong with either of these contenders. If your mind isn’t made up, read our individual reviews to learn more about either mattress.

Quick Comparison: Casper vs. Tempur-Pedic

Casper Original Product Image
Check pricing and availability by clicking the button below
  • Breathable AirScape™
  • Responsive feel
  • 100-night trial period
  • Casper Review
Product image of Tempur-Pedic Tempur-Cloud Compressed Mattress
Check pricing and availability by clicking the button below
Sosha Lewis
Writer

Sosha Lewis is a staff writer for Sleep Advisor.  Lewis is happy that she is able to combine her love of sleep with her love of writing. Lewis also has had articles featured in The Washington Post, Huffington Post, MUTHA Magazine, Charlotte Magazine, and The Charlotte Observer. Her weekly column, Soshally Awkward, is featured on the nationally-syndicated radio show, Bob & Sheri.

She lives in Charlotte, NC with her husband, daughter, and lovable trash-panda of a dog, Olive.

Sleep Advisor