Our 8 Highest Rated Soft (Plush) Mattress Picks For 2021

Transparency Disclosure – We may receive a referral fee for products purchased through the links on our site... Read more here.

It's not easy to find a mattress that strikes a balance between plush comfort and also excels in support, so buying a high-performance soft mattress presents some unique challenges.

Some softer models cater to side sleepers as their construction typically contains more pressure relieving features, however, support is important for spinal alignment as well.

If you enjoy feeling like you're sleeping on a cloud and the gentle “tucked in” sensation of a plush bed, read on.

Comfort doesn’t have to mean you emerge from sleep with a backache, support can provide soft relief as well. We've compiled a list of our favorite soft mattresses that offer quality support as well.

We picked eight of the top beds with a plush feel that you can buy in 2021 to help you to make an easier choice, and have you sleeping like a baby in no time.

small product image of dreamcloud premier DreamCloud Premier
  • Trial Period: 365 Nights
  • Warranty : Lifetime
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
layla bed new medium product image Layla
  • Trial Period: 120 Nights
  • Warranty : Lifetime
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
Brooklyn Aurora small product image Brooklyn Aurora
  • Trial Period: 120 Nights
  • Warranty : 10-Year
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
casper wave hybrid medium image Casper Wave Hybrid
  • Trial Period: 100 Days
  • Warranty : 10 Years
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
casper small product image Casper
  • Trial: 100 Nights
  • Warranty: 10 Years
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
Small Product Image of Zenhaven by Saatva Zenhaven
  • Trial Period: 180 Nights
  • Warranty: 20 Years
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
the alexander signature hybrid small image Alexander Nest Signature
  • Trial Period: 100 Nights
  • Warranty: Lifetime
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE
small product image of copper dreams Copper Dreams
  • Trial Period: 120 Nights
  • Warranty: 10 Year
CLICK HERE FOR PRICE

Top 8 Softest Bed Reviews

DreamCloud Premier – Affordable Luxury

HIGHLIGHTS:

  • Hybrid Mattress
  • Best for Side Sleepers
  • Firmness Level: 5.5/10
  • 365-Night Trial
  • Lifetime Warranty

If you’re on a budget but want something luxurious, DreamCloud Premier has plenty of posh features at a reasonable price point. Starting with its plush EuroTop cover, through the gel-infused memory and conventional foam layers, and down to the durable spring system, you should expect a comfortable and supportive night’s sleep.

What stands out?

  • DreamCloud Premier just might be the best of both worlds; this hybrid has memory foam benefits that melt away pressure points, and springs for support and easy repositioning. It is on the softer side, so side sleepers should love the comfort around the shoulders and hips.
  • The materials are durable and feel expensive but are offered at a fair price, which is great for anyone trying to save a few bucks. Not sure if it is the right choice for you? Once you purchase, it comes with a 365-night trial, so you have plenty of time to decide whether it is the mattress of your dreams.

Layla – Pressure Relief

HIGHLIGHTS:

  • Foam Mattress
  • Great for All Types of Sleepers
  • Firmness Level: 4/10 (Soft) & 7/10 (Firm) — Dual-sided
  • 120-Night Trial
  • Lifetime Warranty

Layla wants to modernize the way we look at memory foam with their innovative cooling technology that uses copper to ferry away heat from the sleeper, who is nestled in a deep cradle that provides fantastic pressure relief. If a deeper hug is not your style, you can flip the mattress over for a firmer bed with a shallower cushioning depth.

What sets this mattress apart?

  • Traditional memory materials are known for their ability to contour to every curve of the body and make pressure points vanish, but the more old-fashioned models have a downside: heat retention. By including copper in their top foam layer and gel in their cover, Layla does a great job of keeping the surface temperature comfortable no matter which side you choose.
  • Layla mattress really delivers in motion isolation, where memory foam mattresses are known to perform extremely well. This is great news for couples who sleep light or have varying sleeping schedules.

Brooklyn Aurora – Amazing Cooling

HIGHLIGHTS:

  • Hybrid Mattress
  • Great for Warm Sleepers
  • Firmness Level: 5/10 (Soft) 7/10 (Medium) 8/10 (Firm)
  • 120-Night Trial
  • 10-Year Warranty

Do you overheat when you're sleeping? The Aurora is one of Brooklyn Bedding’s hybrids, which are cooler than all-foam alternatives. The brand’s careful synthesis of foam and coils give this mattress a unique edge in the hybrid market, and their soft option should give you the plush comfort you prefer.

What makes it unique?

  • This bed is built with a layer of the company’s proprietary TitanFlex™ foams followed by a layer of 8-inch coils that are individually pocketed to help isolate motion. Though all three available firmness levels offer a good blend of comfort and support, the softest version maximizes pressure relief and holds your body in a slightly deeper cradle.
  • Plus, Brooklyn Bedding owns their own factory which allows them to defray a lot of the costs associated with middlemen working the production process. These savings are generously passed on to their customers, which is how they can deliver quality materials at a very attractive price rate.

Casper Wave Hybrid – Spine Alignment

HIGHLIGHTS:

  • Hybrid Mattress
  • Great for All Types of Sleepers
  • Firmness Level: 7/10
  • 100-Day Trial
  • 10-Year Limited Warranty

The Casper Wave Hybrid has created a remarkably comfortable bed while still providing a high level of support. The Wave Hybrid is Casper’s new high-end model, with a unique, innovative design. While it utilizes memory foam, it has a quicker response than most, providing a nice balance between contouring without feeling stuck.

What’s special?

  • The Casper Wave Hybrid has unique gel pods incorporated into their mattress, providing soft yet noticeable support in areas typically needed most, like the hips, lower back, and knees. The memory foam works with the pods to support our body’s most vulnerable areas so that we can sleep comfortably night after night.
  • Beds with a lot of foam on top are rarely known for their cooling measures, but this bed uses convoluted foam and perforations throughout the layers for a breathable feel rather than trapping body heat within the bed. Airscape™ 3 with cooling gel is also a new feature that should prevent overheating.

Casper – All Sleeping Positions

HIGHLIGHTS:

  • Foam Mattress
  • Best for Back and Side Sleepers
  • Firmness Level: 6/10
  • 100 Night Sleep Trial
  • 10-Year Limited Warranty

Casper is one of the top mattress brands in the industry, and it is an extremely versatile option for combination sleepers or couples. Its Zoned Support™ is soft around pressure points like shoulders and hips, yet supportive in areas that need some extra help like the lower back and knees.

What stands out?

  • When air can move quickly through memory foam there is less chance for heat to accumulate, which is Casper’s strategy with its top layer of proprietary foam.
  • The Casper has a gradual firmness that starts soft at the top and gets firmer down to the base. As you push down further, it gets firmer, so heavier parts of the body get the support that they need.
  • Though there is some bounce coming from the base layer, the memory foam here works exceptionally well here to trap vibrations caused by a sleeper’s movements, letting partners sleep in peace.

Zenhaven – Flippable

HIGHLIGHTS:

  • Latex Mattress
  • Great for Back and Side Sleepers
  • Firmness Level: 5/10 (Luxury Plush) 7/10 (Gentle Firm)
  • 180-Night Trial
  • 20-Year Warranty

Latex offers a unique sleep experience because of its quick response time, low heat retention, and pressure-relieving body conformance. This all-natural latex brand comes from the makers of Saatva, a company that endeavors to reduce its carbon footprint. The Talalay foam in this bed provides more bounce and sleeps cooler than many memory foam mattresses.

What is this bed’s best feature?

  • This handcrafted mattress offers dual-sided firmness. The Luxury Plush offers 4.5 inches of gentle comfort that envelops your shape, cradling away pressure built up in your joints, perfect for curvier side sleepers. If the softness is not quite right, a firmer bed is available on the other side.
  • All Saatva brands arrive at your door straight from the manufacturer with free professional installation to set up your new bed, and this service also includes the removal or your previous mattress and foundation.

Alexander Nest Signature – Balanced Feel

HIGHLIGHTS:

  • Hybrid Mattress
  • Great for All Types of Sleepers
  • Firmness Level: 3/10 (Soft) 7/10 (Medium)
  • 100 Night Sleep Trial
  • Lifetime Warranty

Signature is a foam and coil hybrid known for its pressure-relieving qualities. The comfortable contouring of the upper foam layers should be effective for all sleeping positions and body types, great for couples and combination sleepers.

Repositioning can be a struggle if a bed is particularly soft. Alexander has a good amount of springiness because of the Quantum® Edge pocketed coils that are durable and supportive. The Signature’s response helps make readjusting effortless for those with mobility problems.

What’s unique?

  • If you sleep hot, The Signature’s cooling foams should keep you comfortable. While some foam mattresses retain heat, Signature cools down with its phase-changing cover and both gel and copper-infused foam. So while you should get the benefits of contouring memory foam, you can avoid the pitfalls.
  • The foams Nest Bedding meets the CertiPUR-US® standard. They are made without harmful materials such as mercury, lead, and formaldehyde, letting you sleep easily.

Copper Dreams – Budget Choice

HIGHLIGHTS:

  • Foam Mattress
  • Best for Side Sleepers
  • Firmness Level: 6/10
  • 120 Night Sleep Trial
  • 10-Year Warranty

Buying a new mattress can be an expensive investment, but a good night’s sleep doesn’t have to break the bank. Copper Dreams is an affordable option, especially for the quality of materials, which is why it is our Budget Choice.

On Copper Dreams, you should feel contouring from the foam layers that give you a deep hug, keeping those pressure points comfortable. Motion transfer should not be a problem on this mattress, either, which is key for couples, those with pets, or restless children climbing into bed at night.

What’s so special?

  • The bed’s top memory foam layer includes a copper-graphite infusion, providing superior conductivity and drawing excess heat away from the body. This helps in maintaining ideal body temperature throughout the night.
  • By owning their own factory Brooklyn Bedding has enormous control over material and assembly. They even offer boxed delivery, allowing Dreamfoam to save on shipping costs and save you money.

Who Should Sleep on a Softer Model?

Side sleepers are often great matches for soft beds due to their pressure relief and contouring abilities. Of course, this doesn’t mean that they are no good for other sleeping preferences.

However, keep in mind that the softer layers of the bed should allow for an excellent hug, contouring, and support throughout the curves of your entire body. Some back sleepers might also grow to love this feel. However, it would come down to personal preferences and true alignment needs.

People who sleep on the left or right side, on the other hand, can truly benefit from a softer mattress as it can enable them to sink conveniently into the bed, offering great spinal alignment. People who are under 150 pounds of weight might also find the solution suitable, as they may not be able to sink in to relieve pressure adequately otherwise.

Check Out Our Full Guide: Best Mattress for Side Sleepers

Who Shouldn’t Sleep on a Soft Bed?

An ultra soft mattress tends to mean a more pronounced sinkage. People who are overweight or who weight more than 150 pounds may need to consider avoiding overly soft beds. They may need something firmer for the enhanced support.

On the other hand, those of you who prefer sleeping on their backs or tummies tend to be better off with a medium-firm bed. This can provide clear support and should make sure that your spine is aligned correctly.

Additionally, if you are simply not a fan of contouring and the expressed foam hug that most of the softer units deliver, you might do better to look for something slightly sturdier.

Read Our Complete Guide: Best Mattresses For Heavy People

Benefits of a Soft Mattress

There is a lot of merit to owning a softer mattress. They provide serious comfort in most cases and many of them can accommodate some varied sleeping preferences as well.

Finding this type of mattress can help you experience the cloud-like sleeping sensation that many people dream about.

The most significant benefits are revealed for the proper sleeping position, and for most people that is the side sleeping position. The soft model can help make sure there are as little pressure points between your body and the bed and that it contours your body’s shape.

Light-weighted people can also experience the benefits of a soft mattress as they can receive a proper amount of sinkage and hug that they may not be able to on something harder.

A Woman in Bed Sleeping while a Rooster Crows Illustration

Buyer’s Guide

Firmness Level vs. Support

Among the very first things that you should take into account when purchasing a mattress is the actual support. Firmness is not necessarily the same thing as support. These are actually two different properties in any given bed, and there is a fine line between them that you ought to be aware of.

While they do tend to work closely together, they are far from being the same thing. A good level of mattress support means that your spine is correctly aligned and that there are no pressure points between your body and the bed. This could help you alleviate back, hip, or shoulder pain.

The firmness, on the other hand, is the overall feel the mattress delivers. Is it firm or is it soft? That’s what this particular characteristic is all about.

Consider the Temperature

Softer mattresses are usually made out of memory foam (but not always), and this is a material that can bring the most substantial heat retention if it is not a modern design. If your bed retains a lot of the heat, you may just wake up in the middle of the night sweating through your PJs.

If heat is a problem for you, consider the construction of your soft mattress and make sure that there is airflow or that there are other cooling measures in place. This will help dissipate the heat and will bring more coolness to your bed, in the hopes that you rest soundly.

With this in mind, there are certain materials which bring additional cooling to the bed. Latex and gel are amongst them. They may slightly raise the price, but are becoming more common.

Learn More: Our Top Rated Cooling Beds Reviewed

Animated Gif of Latex Mattress Breathability

Think About Edge Support

Edge support is one thing that a lot of people disregard because it isn't always of huge importance to every individual or couple. However, it can be important if you are part of a couple that needs some more space. As a general rule of thumb, softer beds tend to be more challenged with edge support, though not always.

If you sleep with someone else, you may find yourself using the edges a lot more often than not. This is an example of when you’d truly appreciate proper support in this area. It allows for a proper usage of the entire surface, which can be something to consider.

With this in mind, proper edge support also helps amorous nighttime activities. This can help co-sleepers to maximize space, and lessens the potential to put a damper on the passion.

Material/Type

Illustration of Memory Foam, Latex and Innerspring Mattress

Softness can be delivered by a few different materials, including memory foam, latex, and innerspring. As you can probably guess on your own, memory foam is the established and predominant leader in the segment because of its properties.

Latex is more responsive, and it does have a certain bounce that’s not always well-received by those looking for truly soft sensation. Innerspring, on the other hand, has even more expressed bounce most of the time and there is also some serious pushback. However, you can still find soft versions of both types if you know where to look.

Read Our Full Guide: Type of Mattresses

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a Soft Mattress Cause Back Pain?

Back pain is a hurdle for quite a lot of sleepers. It could occur for any sleeper without any regard to the position that you prefer to sleep in. It could also be attributed to a range of different factors.

A softer option which lacks the necessary support and sinks too much could easily cause back pain. This, of course, is different based on the sleep position you prefer. For example, if you like sleeping on your back or stomach, you may want to limit sinkage more than a side sleeper to prevent misalignment.

Read More: Top Rated Mattress for Back Pain

Illustration of a Woman Sleeping on Her Side on a Soft Mattress

Can a Plush Topper be a Good Option?

Yes, a soft topper can be a great choice, but not so much if you have an older bed that is already starting to lose its integrity. A mattress topper should be matched with solid support below to bring tremendous comfort.

Of course, it’s important to account for the capabilities of your own bed. A puffy mattress with a softer topper might not really make much sense. Soft mattress toppers are usually great for firmer beds to help compensate for the comfort while not putting the support in jeopardy.

Conclusion

There are quite a few things that you should take into account when it comes to choosing the best soft mattress. You need to make sure that you balance between the comfort and the firmness in a manner which is supportive so that you can make sure that no issues take place down the line.

Hopefully, we’ve done a good job helping you get there. The “soft” beds we’ve reviewed help convey comfort without putting your back in jeopardy. Make sure to take a look at all our mattress reviews for more choices and budget and firmness filters.

Resources:

+ posts

Rachael is a content writer for Sleep Advisor who loves combining her enthusiasm for writing and wellness. She’s had a passion for writing since she was a kid when she wrote awful poetry. She’s honed her craft quite a bit since then and considers herself a lucky duck to get paid to do what she loves.

Embracing the remote work life, she occasionally takes her work on the road and lives out her travel writer pipe dream.

In her free time, she attempts to meditate regularly, rides her bike to Trader Joe’s, and enjoys trying every type of food that she can get her hands on.

Sleep Advisor