Written by Olivera Jancikin, Content Writer
Do you love your pillow? If you’re reading this, then there’s a chance you may have fallen out of love with it. Having a quality pillow makes all the difference when it comes to improving your sleep. You can have the best mattress, but you’re unlikely to get a good night’s rest until you also invest in a quality pillow.
Our review of the I Love Pillow Out Cold model is here to provide you with a possible new pillow to adore. The Out Cold pillow is a cooling memory foam model with multiple sizes and loft options. As such, we think it could be a good fit for nearly all sleepers who like a cooling sensation and quick-responding memory foam.
In this review, we’ll discuss how the pillow feels and performs, explaining its features, pros, and cons, to help you figure out if it’s the right choice for your needs and preferences.
Who Is the I Love Pillow Best for?
Pros: Who Might Like the I Love Pillow:
- Hot sleepers – This pillow has a cooling side that stays cool to the touch throughout the night. As such, it’s a perfect fit for those who frequently overheat and sweat when sleeping.
- Side sleepers – Side sleepers can do well with a medium loft, but the brand goes the extra mile by creating a specific Side Sleeper model that’s made for those who like sleeping this way. This pillow has a curve for your shoulder and makes for an excellent addition if you’re fighting pressure buildup.
- Memory foam fans – The brand’s custom foam is breathable, cooling, and made from natural materials. In addition, it offers support, pressure relief, and a quick response.
Cons: Who Might Not Like the I Love Pillow:
- Those who need a smaller pillow – The Out Cold pillow only comes in Queen and King only.
- Stomach sleepers – Although this pillow is available in a low loft, its feel is likely too firm for most stomach sleepers.
- People who prefer adjustable pillows – This pillow has a block of memory foam for its core, so you can’t adjust its loft or fluffiness.
Sleep Advisor’s Testing Methodology
We tested this pillow in various sleeping positions to figure out who could benefit from it the most. Although there are multiple loft options for various sleeping positions, we tested the Medium profile as it’s the most versatile option. Using first-hand testing gave us insight into its durability, off-gassing, temperature regulation, support capabilities, and more.
What is the I Love Pillow Made of?
Cover
This pillow has a unique cover with two different fabrics on each side. One side is made from a polyester-based micro-mink, while the other is a blend of cotton and polyester. The latter also features the brand’s phase change material embedded in for additional freshness and cooling.
Core
The core is a blend of polyurethane foam with a quick response and a lightweight feel. Although it’s memory foam, the core is breathable, which is another plus for those who sleep hot.
I Love Pillow Firmness & Feel
Firmness
This pillow has a medium firmness that should fit most people. However, some sleepers, specifically those who sleep on their stomach, would probably benefit more from a softer pillow. Nonetheless, the Out Cold should be a good match for most sleepers as its medium firmness allows just enough sinkage for pressure relief without letting the head sink all the way to the mattress.
Feel
The pillow feels cool and comfortable, also responding to pressure rather quickly. It adapts to your neck and head instantly as you move, so you shouldn’t have to worry about waking up with pressure buildup.
The foam does a good job of supporting your head to keep your neck aligned with the rest of the spine. Plus, you can flip the pillow over depending on the feel you want at the moment.
Loft
The Out Cold pillow comes in Low, Medium, Contour, and Side Sleeper loft options. The Low model would generally be better stomach sleepers and those with a smaller body frame, though stomach sleepers might prefer a softer pillow altogether.
The Medium is the most versatile and should work best for side and back sleepers, as well as those with a medium-sized body frame. Lastly, Contour and Side Sleeper are perfect for side sleepers.
Weight (Density of the Pillow)
Although this pillow has a block of memory foam as its core, it’s lightweight. The foam is made to be breathable, which is why it feels lighter than traditional memory foam pillows.
Sleeping on the I Love Pillow
We felt that this pillow’s cooling cover enhances comfort and could improve your sleeping experience. The medium firmness may not be for everyone, but we’d say it should fit most people sleeping on their side and back. If you’re a side sleeper, you may also want to consider the Side Sleeper and Contour loft options.
One thing we didn’t like when sleeping on this pillow is that it’s a bit too firm and lofty (specifically the Medium) for stomach sleeping.
| Side Sleepers | Back Sleepers | Stomach Sleepers |
| ★★★☆ | ★★★ | ★☆☆ |
Side Sleepers
This pillow is an excellent match for side sleepers, specifically those with a medium-sized body frame. The Medium loft is a good option to keep your neck aligned while not too high that your head is too upright. However, some may prefer the Side Sleeper or Contour options.
Back Sleepers
Back sleepers should also feel well-supported by the Medium loff as it’s tall enough to fill the gap between your neck and the bed. On top of that, the pillow won’t let you sink too deeply, which means your head should remain aligned with the rest of the body.
Stomach Sleepers
Some stomach sleepers may like the Medium version, but we suggest the Low loft as a more suitable option. Stomach sleepers need a thinner pillow to keep the head aligned with the body, especially those with a smaller frame. With that in mind, these pillows, even the Low model, might still be too firm for stomach sleepers.
I Love Pillow Sizing Options & Pricing
| Size | Dimensions | Price w/o Discount |
| Queen Low Queen Medium Queen Contour Queen Side Sleeper | 26”x16”x4” 26″x16″x5″ 26″x16″x6″ 26″x16″x6″ | $139.99 $139.99 $139.99 $139.99 |
| King Low King Medium King Contour | 33″x17″x4″ 33″x17″x5″ 33″x17″x6″ | $179.99 $179.99 $179.99 |
Temperature
5/5
If we’d have to pick one thing that stands out about this pillow, it’s cooling. The cooling comes from its cover, but the core is also breathable. As such, we think this pillow an excellent choice for hot sleepers.
Support
4/5
The Out Cold pillow offers good support thanks to its medium firmness and quick response. The pillow adapts to your head and neck but doesn’t allow you to sink too deeply. For this reason, you should always feel propped up just enough to have your spine aligned in various positions.
Durability
4/5
Although it’s lightweight, the pillow feels well-made. Starting with the cover, it shows high-quality materials and good craftsmanship, so we’d say it can last several years without showing signs of wear and tear.
Comfort
5/5
The Out Cold pillow is a comfortable one, especially for those who sleep hot. The combination of support and pressure relief helps ensure a great experience, and while it’s not a traditional adjustable pillow, you have four loft/design selections for more customized comfort.
Off-Gassing
3/5
We didn’t notice too much off-gassing odor coming from this pillow despite being made from memory foam. The company says their foam is made from natural materials, so this may be the reason why. However, any odors you may notice should dissipate within the first day.
Allergens
2/5
The Out Cold pillow doesn’t have any certifications or hypoallergenic materials that indicate it’s specifically suitable for those with allergies. However, this pillow’s cover is removable and machine-washable, which should help keep minimize allergens like dirt and dust mites.
Cleaning & Care
5/5
One of the best things about this pillow is how easy it is to keep it clean. The cover is removable and washable, making it a breeze to maintain. However, the core isn’t machine-washable, though you can spot clean it with a damp cloth.
Sleep Trial & Warranty
4/5
The Out Cold pillow comes with a three-year warranty and a 100-night trial, giving you plenty of time to decide whether it’s the right choice for you. The company offers a full refund should you return the pillow before the trial is up.
I Love Pillow Frequently Asked Questions
What is I Love Pillow Made Of?
This pillow is made from memory foam and has a plush cover to enhance its overall comfort. The design features two fabrics on each side of the pillow, allowing a different feel on each side. The memory foam core is breathable, but what brings the most cooling is the phase-change material in the cover.
What is the Trial for I Love Pillow?
Sleepers get a 100-night trial to test how the I Love Pillow fits their needs and preferences. This is a fairly long trial and should give you ample time to sleep in various positions before deciding if this pillow is the right for you.
How to Wash I Love Pillow?
The core of this pillow is only suitable for spot-cleaning, but the cover is removable and machine-washable. This makes it easy to maintain clean and fresh, but you’re still advised to use a pillowcase.
How Does the I Love Pillow Compare to Other Pillows?
I Love Pillow vs Nectar Copper Pillow
Nectar Copper Pillow
A cooling pillow from Nectar designed to help hot sleepers get a good night’s rest.
Who Should Get the I Love Pillow?
- Side sleepers
- People with a medium frame
- Back sleepers
Who Should Get the Nectar Copper Pillow?
- Extremely hot sleepers
- Those after a Standard size pillow
- Combination sleepers
Link to Nectar Copper Pillow Review.
I Love Pillow vs Nest Easy Breather Pillow
Nest Easy Breather Side Sleeper Pillow
A shredded memory foam pillow with cooling fabric.
Sleep Advisor Score
4.50 / 5
Read Full Review
Who Should Get the I Love Pillow?
- Fans of memory foam
- Sleepers who want more customization options
- Those who need a longer trial
Who Should Get the Nest Easy Breather Pillow?
- People who like down alternative
- Side sleepers
- Back sleepers
Link to Nest Easy Breather Pillow Review.
Our Final Thoughts on the I Love Pillow
I Love My Pillow delivers products that you’ll love. While it may sound a little under the nose, this is the best way for us to summarize these products. Of course, it would ultimately depend on your personal preferences to pick up the one that suits your sleeping requirements the most, but all of them are quite capable of fulfilling serious standards.
These are designed to fit a range of sleepers, so it may be a bit tricky to pinpoint which option is best for you. Luckily, the company offers a lengthy trial, making it easy to replace a size or loft.
The Out Cold pillow combines pressure relief with support, which is why it feels so versatile. Plus, the medium firmness is an excellent pick for side and back sleepers, especially when combined with some of the loft options. Overall, this pillow earned a 4 out of 5.
Olivera Jancikin
Content Writer
About Author
Olivera is a content writer for Sleep Advisor and is enthusiastic about sleep. She firmly believes in the benefits of daytime naps on top of getting a full 8-hour sleep at night.
Combination Sleeper