Why settle when can you have it all?
Zoned comfort and natural substances, check. Pressure relief and lumbar support, also check. These brands throw in everything but the kitchen sink, so how will you decide between them?
This Avocado vs. Brentwood Cedar comparison will break down the differences between these beds created by companies that believe in organic products and healthy living, so you can get an idea of which should suit your individual needs.
Quick Comparison: Avocado vs. Brentwood Cedar
- Eco-friendly bed
- Traditional innerspring feel
- Affordable price
- Reduce your carbon footprint
- Pressure relief and support
- Bed with bounce
Comparing Construction (Materials & Quality)
When this latex and steel coil hybrid is shipped, the company will compress it into a box.
The cover features GOTS organic cotton and wool that is meant to promote temperature regulation and moisture-wicking. Wool rosettes create a button tufting design that reduces the use of adhesives. The total height of this bed is 11 inches, unless you add the optional pillow top.
- The top layer consists of a 2-inch Dunlop latex certified by GOLS designed to promote airflow and pressure relief.
- The second layer offers 3 comfort zones with varying degrees of pressure relief or pushback due to different gauges being used in the 8-inch Steel Coils. The steel has been upcycled to reduce waste.
- The final layer should provide a stable foundation for the upper materials as they rest on this 1-inch Dunlop latex.
- The perimeter puts reinforced coils to work to prevent too much sinkage when sleepers lie along the edge of this bed.
Brentwood Cedar Construction
This hybrid combines latex and coils, along with natural materials that reduce the chemicals present in this bed. The mattress is compressed and boxed when shipped.
This 13-inch mattress features a stretch-knit organic cotton cover and Summerweight New Zealand wool for enhanced temperature regulation. Hydra silica sand is used as a natural fire barrier.
- The upper layer contains a 2-inch Dunlop latex. This material should be responsive with good airflow and lots of bounce.
- The second layer consists of 2-inch Grooved Latex that should further promote airflow to prevent overheating. There are 3 zoned areas that feature slightly different shapes to provide the proper support and compression for the hips, shoulders, and legs.
- The third layer boasts a thin layer consisting of Flaxseed which acts as a clean, natural transition between the comfort and support levels.
- The fourth layer splits the 8-inch Individually Wrapped Coils into 5 comfort zones. This coil system should provide ample bounce that aids in repositioning so shoppers do not feel as though they are “stuck” in the foam.
- The bottom layer is comprised of an inch of Coconut Husk to create a natural foundation for the entire mattress system.
- The perimeter offers enhanced edge support due to the reinforced coils around the edge of this product.
Comparing Firmness (Support & Feel)
In order to give you an idea of how these products should feel to most shoppers, we have placed them both on our comfort (firmness) scale. This scale uses rankings starting at 1 and going up to 10 to indicate the comfort level of each item, 1 being very soft while 10 is very firm.
Avocado is ranked at a medium-firm 7. The Cedar features a score of 6, which should feel medium or medium-firm depending on the shopper.
Both beds should offer natural temperature regulation thanks to the wool inside the covers. Zoned, individually pocketed coils should allow all sorts of sleep types to find a comfortable position as each zone offers a different level of pushback or pressure relief for even weight distribution.
The coil systems in either bed are designed to support heavier sleepers. Back and stomach sleepers who prefer a firmer comfort level should enjoy either mattress. Side sleepers can opt for the slightly softer Cedar or they could add the available softer pillow topper to the Avocado mattress.
Comparing Sinkage and Bounce
Shoppers should not sink very deeply into either bed. Instead, they should float on top of a gentle cradle.
Avocado should provide a moderate bounce that aids in easy repositioning. Brentwood should provide higher amounts of bounce, which may be ideal for anyone especially concerned with mobility issues.
Comparing Motion Transfer
Avocado should do well in absorbing motion transfer, as compared to most innerspring or hybrid products, and those very concerned with motion control may add the available pillow top to further isolate motion. The Cedar may allow a little more movement to travel through the bed due to its higher levels of bounce.
Co-sleepers should rest easy on either bed with few disruptions from their partners’ movements. If enhanced motion control is a major concern for very sensitive sleepers, the Avocado should work well.
Comparing Edge Support
There are reinforced coils around the perimeter of either mattress, which should promote enhanced edge support for either bed. Sprawlers who like to hug the edge of their mattress should feel well-supported by either brand. However, the thicker nature of the Cedar may allow a little more compression than what might be seen in the Avocado, which places its coil system higher in the mattress.
Avocado vs. Brentwood Cedar Compared Side-by-Side
|Cover||Organic cotton, New Zealand wool||Organic cotton, Summerweight New Zealand wool|
|Materials||Dunlop latex, steel coils||Flaxseed, coconut husk, hydra silica sand, Dunlop latex, coils|
|Cooling||Wool, individually pocketed coils||Wool, pocketed coils, aerated latex|
|Sinkage||Gentle Cradle||Gentle Cradle|
|Warranty||25 years||25 years|
|Trial Period||1 year||1 year|
|Certifications||OEKO-TEX®, eco-INSTITUT®, GREENGUARD Gold, GOTS, GOLS, Made Safe||OEKO-TEX®, eco-INSTITUT®, GOTS|
|Adjustable Base Compatible||Yes||Yes|
|Shipping||Free in the United States, In-Home Delivery service is available for additional fee||Free in the contiguous United States|
|Made in the USA||Yes||Yes|
|Size||Avocado Price (w/o discount)||Brentwood Price (w/o discount)|
Should I Buy Avocado or Brentwood Cedar?
How could you possibly decide between these supportive and natural hybrid beds? Maybe our sleeper recommendations will help you determine which product is right for you. Check them out below.
We Would Recommend Buying Avocado if You are Looking for:
- A peaceful co-sleeper experience. Enhanced edge support should allow couples to give themselves a little wiggle room, spreading out toward the edge without sacrificing stability. A higher level of motion control should minimize the amount of disturbance felt by partners’ movements.
- Zoned support. The springs inside this mattress are divided into zones that promise varying amounts of compression. This should ensure that various areas of the body receive the proper support needed to maintain a neutral spine.
- A lower price point. This product is priced competitively for the hybrid market, especially when the multiple certifications and quality construction are taken into consideration.
We Would Recommend Buying Brentwood if You are Looking for:
- Enhanced mobility. High levels of bounce and a responsive latex material should make repositioning a snap for combination sleepers or people who struggle with mobility.
- Additional comfort zones. The unique construction of this hybrid provides zoning in both the second latex layer and the coil system, which promises just the right amount of support and pressure relief for different body parts.
- More natural materials. This product makes use of natural materials such as flaxseed and coconut husk to reduce the number of chemicals, additives, or processed components found inside. Multiple certifications promise a clean and healthy sleeping experience.
If you are looking for a hybrid with zoned comfort and good temperature regulation, you’ve met your match in either of these beds! Avocado should be a must-have for couples seeking enhanced motion control and edge support. The Cedar shakes things up with its unique and natural construction and double zoned layers.
Now head back to the top of this review to check out our individual write-ups for each mattress! Or if you want to search further, you can take a look at our top 12 picks here.